No rest for the travelers?
ODOT says Government Camp rest stop flushes too much money down the drain
Good luck finding anyone who's looking forward to the Oct. 31 closure of the Government Camp rest stop, the only public restroom on Highway 26 between Madras and Portland.
The rest stop has provided relief to thousands - maybe millions - of people over the years.
'It's a question of public safety,' said Joel Horning, a resident of Redmond. 'It's a place to stop, refresh, get out of the car -- not just a place to stop for the bathroom. It doesn't make sense to close something so used.'
Horning travels between Central Oregon and Portland almost every two weeks and always takes a break here. He wondered if he would end up stopping at campgrounds or on the side of the road, and dreaded both scenarios.
The rest stop also provides the only public stop along the highway between Sandy and Hood River. A Monday survey of the numerous rest-stop users before the start of ski season revealed a number of travelers from the north.
Bernadette Chumley of Woodland, Wash., often travels through to Bend. 'When you gotta go, you gotta go,' she said. 'They better bring a big clean-up truck out here if they're going to close the rest stop.'
The only entity that may be looking forward to the rest stop's closure is the Oregon Department of Transportation, which operates the public restroom. Apparently, ODOT's finances are in need of a little relief.
ODOT's 2-percent reduction in its maintenance budget has pitted the rest stop against snowplows, much to the grief of bathroom breakers, tourism advocates and local businesses.
ODOT spokesman Don Hamilton argued that, unlike rest-stop facilities along Interstate 5, the Government Camp facility is not really full service, pointing out that trucks usually can't stop in its parking lot when it's jammed with skiers.
'We're in a situation where government is providing services for private businesses like the ski resorts,' Hamilton said.
The rest stop has cost ODOT nearly $475,000 over the past six years. While $70,000 annually was sufficient in 2006, its total cost has risen to nearly $90,000 in the past three years due largely to vandalism issues, Hamilton said.
Regarding the vandalism, Horning countered that he doesn't see it as an issue. Suggesting more lights around the building to discourage vandalism, he thinks rest stops between Portland and Eugene are comparably vandalized, and 'those aren't being closed down.'
In letters to the Oregon Transportation Commission and state legislators last week, Clackamas County Chairwoman Charlotte Lehan begged that the rest stop remain open until an alternative source of funding could be found.
'This facility is of vital interest to a broad array of residents, businesses, local and federal governments, recreational users, commuters and visitors,' Lehan wrote.
On Aug. 22 and Sept. 12, the U.S. Forest Service, Villages at Mt. Hood and Government Camp, the ski operators (Summit, Skibowl and Timberline) and other business interests met with ODOT to come up with a short- and long-term strategies to keep the rest area open. They negotiated with ODOT to delay the closure that was originally set for June 30, but Hamilton says ODOT can't delay it any further.
An initial letter April 22, 2009, to Clackamas County, the Government Camp Community Planning Organization and the Forest Service outlined reasons for this year's planned closure of the rest area. The letter, which referenced the availability of other planned public restrooms, flew under the radar on that assumption, making emergency meetings necessary.
'There's been a lot less notice on this than I'd think is necessary, so I would hope that ODOT takes that into account in reconsidering their decision,' said Peter Watts, an attorney who volunteers as chairman of Clackamas County Tourism Development Council.
ODOT suggested that Clackamas County's assume the site's approximately $7,500-per-month maintenance costs for a six-month period in order to keep the restroom open while the group works on a longer-term strategy. Any change in the operation would require a transfer of the conditional-use permit of ODOT's current restroom facility on Forest Service land.
The county has also experienced recent reductions to its $800 million annual budget and doesn't have an identified pot of money to draw from for restrooms on state-owned highways.
County Tourism Director Danielle Cowan wonders why, in ODOT's total biennial budget of more than $5 billion, the transportation agency couldn't find a way to keep one of its most popular services open at a less than $200,000 portion of that total.
'We are not in the rest area business, ODOT is. We think they should find this rest area to be as important as the many others they operate, especially since it is the only option on that entire stretch of highway,' Cowan said.
Acknowledging that any financial reduction is a difficult balancing act, Hamilton responded that ODOT's budgeting process received input from thousands of Oregonians through online comments and through testimony given in Salem.