Hayes' ocean expertise raises questions
As governor's adviser, fiancee landed deal as marine consultant
Four years ago, Cylvia Hayes had little experience working on ocean policy.
But within 14 months, Gov. John Kitzhabers fiancee became a sought-after expert invited to speak at the February 2012 Coastal States Organization meeting in Washington, D.C., followed by a speech at the Oregon State of the Coast conference and she landed a contract worth at least $21,000 to promote marine conservation policy.
Newly-released emails reveal how Hayes made the transition. Soon after voters elected Kitzhaber to a third term as governor, Hayes began to work with state and federal employees to create a new role for herself as an ocean health advocate. Hayes directed an aide in the governors office to track news about marine issues, sought suggestions for events she should attend, and requested talking points for the 2012 speech in Washington, D.C., according to emails released by the state.
Initially, Hayes said she would champion ocean issues in her unpaid role as Oregons first lady. That changed in February 2013, when Hayes quietly signed on as a paid ocean policy advocate for the environmental public relations firm Resource Media, an arrangement first reported by Willamette Week. Resource Media wanted Hayes to build stronger commitment among key West Coast audiences to develop and support policies that conserve our marine resources and boost our West Coast economy, according to an unsigned version of the contract released by the governors office.
The contract called for Resource Media to pay Hayes $20,600, plus up to $5,300 in reimbursement of travel expenses for roughly two months of work, from Feb. 19 through April 30, 2013. The true extent of Hayes work for Resource Media is unclear. Hayes said the contract actually continued through Dec. 31, 2013, but she would not say whether Resource Media increased her compensation for the extended period.
Scott Miller, president of Resource Media, wrote in a Dec. 30 email that Hayes work for the company wrapped up months ago.
Hayes said this was not the first time she was paid to work on ocean issues, but declined to provide any specific examples of previous projects and employers. State ethics law prohibits public officials from using their positions for financial gain, and the governors lawyer Liani Reeves has acknowledged Kitzhabers staff always treated Hayes as an official.
Green business in the desert
The Resource Media ocean policy contract was a departure from the sustainable living, renewable energy and green jobs work on which Hayes focused since she moved to Oregons high desert in 1997 and launched her consulting business, now called 3E Strategies. Hayes worked on a campaign to preserve livability in Bend, organized a green building and renewable energy fair, and held educational talks on similar topics at the local community college, according to reports in The Bulletin newspaper.
Former Gov. Ted Kulongoski appointed Hayes in 2006 to a renewable energy task force, whose recommendations eventually would form the basis for state legislation.
Hayes took on increasingly high-profile work, including a $135,000 state contract to write a green job creation plan and a project to help the Redmond Municipal Airport build sustainably and obtain state clean energy incentives.
Still, there is no evidence Hayes was hired to work on marine issues until after she got involved in ocean policy as first lady.
Hayes has a different view of her experience, and said she always was interested in ocean issues.
My history of involvement with ocean and marine issues goes all the way back to college where I took training in oceanography and marine biology and at that time intended to become a marine biologist, Hayes wrote in a response to emailed questions. I have done a lot of paid work over the years related to the land and water damage caused by carbon emissions and fossil fuels.
Hayes takes on ocean role
After Kitzhaber had been in office for about a year, Hayes contacted state and federal employees for help charting a course for her first lady initiative on oceans.
On Dec. 20, 2011, Hayes participated in a conference call with employees of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and U.S. Department of the Interior. The topic was opportunities for Oregons first lady to help with outreach for the White Houses national ocean policy.
Federal employees agreed to provide talking points to Hayes. They also promised to identify other governors spouses Hayes could approach about ocean issues at a 2012 National Governors Association meeting, according to a memorandum recapping the call.
At the time, Hayes also was receiving updates on ocean issues from an employee in the governors office.
The aide, Mary Rowinski, had set up a Google alert to search for news on Oregon ocean problems relating to national ocean issues, and she forwarded the results to Hayes. One Google news alert that caught Hayes attention was for a Natural Resources Defense Council blog post on Californias ocean conservation initiatives.
Good stuff from California, Hayes wrote on Dec. 27, 2011, when she forwarded the email to the governors natural resources policy adviser Richard Whitman, and Ed Bowles, Fish Division administrator for the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife. We need to tell the Oregon success story and hopefully figure out a way to better link these efforts.
The same day, Hayes emailed Whitman and Bowles to request suggestions for events she could attend as part of her ocean initiative.
Greetings Gents, Hayes wrote. Attached is the very DRAFT starting point calendar for my engagement in the ocean health issue. Please take a look and let me know if you know of any key dates, conferences, campaigns, etc. that it would make sense for me to consider. I look forward to getting the write-up of your ideas for my engagement on this.
Bowles said recently that he did not recall responding to the first lady, and Whitman referred questions to a spokeswoman for the governor, who did not respond to questions.
Hayes would again call upon Bowles for help a couple months later, this time to request talking points for her Feb. 27, 2012, speech on Oregons ocean policy successes at the Coastal States Organization meeting in Washington, D.C.
I am sure youre a bit busy, with all the new marine reserves and all!! Hayes wrote in a Feb. 22, 2012, email to Bowles. But please do try to get a few Oregon highlight talking points to me as soon as possible.
Two days later, Bowles sent three pages of talking points that focused on Oregons ocean management successes, including a marine reserves program established by the Legislature in 2009.
As first lady, Hayes also had unique access to state scientists whose expertise would be helpful to her business.
On Jan. 17, 2012, Hayes arranged a private briefing with Oregon State University scientists at the governors mansion. They presented information about marine reserves, fisheries and ocean acidification due to carbon dioxide emissions, one of the issues on which Resource Media would hire Hayes to work.
Hayes continued to meet in 2012 with other state employees to seek opportunities to work on ocean issues. It was fun to brainstorm with you yesterday about the tsunami debris issue, as well as finding potential venues for you to lend your voice to speak for ocean issues, Caren Braby, marine resources program manager for ODFW wrote in a March 6, 2012, email to Hayes.
Then in early 2013, Hayes emails with ODFW staff stopped abruptly. Bowles said in an interview that Hayes interest in working with ODFW to promote ocean health quickly ebbed, and he had not been in contact with her much since 2012.
Initially, she was pretty interested in getting very involved, and I dont think a lot of that panned out, Bowles said. You get spread pretty thin, I would assume, doing all the first lady duties.
Hayes involvement in ocean issues did continue in 2013, but the speeches she made that year one on ocean acidification in May at the University of California, Irvine, and one in June on coastal communities responses to global challenges at Capitol Hill Ocean Week in Washington, D.C. were on behalf of Resource Media.
Given the severity of the ocean acidification issue and the fact that the Pacific Northwest is being hit by this problem harder and sooner than nearly any other place on the planet, I thought I could do the most good by focusing directly on this issue rather than just addressing ocean issues in general as a first lady initiative, Hayes wrote in a response to questions.
Meanwhile, the stronger commitment to ocean health that Resource Media hired Hayes to work on appeared to be materializing.
In August 2013, Kitzhabers Natural Resources Policy Director Richard Whitman signed a memorandum of understanding with his counterpart in California state government, to create a panel of scientists from the two states to inform decision makers of the impacts of ocean acidification on the West Coast.
Scott Miller, the president of Resource Media, wrote in an email that Hayes was not hired to influence any government policies.
The reach of the work was focused on building a general commitment to ocean protection primarily among coastal industries, scientists and academics and did not target any specific policy or campaign in Oregon or any other state, Miller wrote.Add a comment